Ice Cream Maker

Best Ice Cream Maker – Top 10 Picks

The following article will compare the best ice cream makers available today and help you decide which one is right for you and your family. What could be better on a hot summer day than to indulge in homemade ice cream? You always know what the ingredients are; it is made with only the all-natural ingredients you add to it making it not only better tasting but better for you. You can have the fun of creating your own flavors and experimenting with toppings, and all sorts of add-ins.

What about peanut butter ice cream with brownies? Or mint chocolate chip ice cream with fudge swirls? The sky is the limit when you are able to make your own. And it is surprisingly not as difficult as you might think. Today's automatic ice cream makers do all the work for you. Just add the ingredients and then a few hours later, yummy homemade ice cream!

Comparison Table

[amazon box=”B01LA8IBPG, B004N8KD5M, B003KYSLMW, B0009A0N4E, B015XOPJR6, B005083ECS, B0002IES80, B009OZ62IG, B00CFIKO3S, B00004RDF0″ template=”table”]

Ice Cream Maker FAQ

ice cream cone

Image Source: Pixabay

There are many types of ice cream makers with varying degrees of automation. We have collected all the information about ten of the best ice cream makers on the market today and have done all the hard work for you. Let our research guide you to the best ice cream maker for your family.

1. What Is an Ice Cream Maker?

2. What Does an Ice Cream Maker Do?

3. How Does an Ice Cream Maker Work?

4. Where Can You Buy the Best Ice Cream Makers?

How We Reviewed The Best Ice Cream Makers

We researched the following ice cream makers based on features available, price, pros and cons, warranty and product reviews to formulate the best possible list of products from which you can choose. We wanted to find products that had consistent good reviews with hundreds of customers as well as the highest-quality features that will yield the best ice cream you can create for your family and friends.

Overall Price Range of These Best Ice Cream Makers

ice cream sundae

Image Source: Pixabay

 We wanted to supply a good variation in types of ice cream makers from both high-end and those more affordable for all budget levels. Each of the ice cream makers we included on our best ice cream makers list we determined would be an excellent option. No matter which you choose you will create delicious desserts and family fun for years. The ice cream makers on our list range in price from around $50 up to $300.

What We Reviewed

  • Nostalgia Electrics ICMW400 4-Quart Wooden Bucket Electric Ice Cream Maker
  • Whynter ICM-15LS
  • Cuisinart ICE-21
  • Hamilton Beach 68330N
  • Chef'n Sweet Spot
  • Yonanas Frozen Dessert Maker
  • KitchenAid 2 Quart Ice Cream Maker Stand Mixer Attachment
  • Breville Smart Scoop
  • Donvier 837450
  • Lello 4080 Musso Lussino

[amazon link=”B01LA8IBPG” title=”Nostalgia Electrics ICMW400 4-Quart Wooden Bucket Electric Ice Cream Maker” /]

[amazon box=”B01LA8IBPG”]

Price

Features

Warranty

This product can be found on Amazon for around $50.

Reminiscent of old-fashioned ice cream makers, this unit is a fast and easy way to make four quarts of ice cream, frozen yogurt, or gelato. It features a locking motor mount, easy-to-clean bucket and a 4-quart aluminum canister. Add your ingredients into the aluminum canister, place it in the middle of the bucket, layer with ice and salt and allow the electric motor to do the rest. The durable churn paddle produces delicious creamy homemade ice cream while the easy-clean plastic liner provides easy cleanup.

This product comes with a one-year limited warranty.

Pros

  • Works best with Nostalgia Ice Cream Mixes
  • Easy-to-clean plastic liner
  • See-thru lid for easy viewing and freezer storage
  • Powerful electric motor does all the churning
  • Motor locks into place keeping all parts secure
  • Real wood construction
  • Recipes included in manual

Cons

  • Bucket was not actually made of wood
  • Spinning action seemed to slow over time
  • Inexpensively made

[amazon link=”B004N8KD5M” title=”Whynter ICM-15LS” /]

[amazon box=”B004N8KD5M”]

Price

Features

Warranty

This product can be found on Amazon for around $270.

The Whynter ICM-15LS stainless steel frozen dessert ice cream maker makes many types of desserts in about 30-40 minutes. This versatile, self-freezing ice cream maker allows you to not only make premium ice cream but also refreshing sorbets, Italian gelato, sherbets, fresh frozen yogurts and other treats. A built-in powerful compressor freezer allows for continuous use without the inconvenience of having to pre-freeze the mixing bowl. Not only is it so much easier, it also tastes a lot better. The stainless steel exterior and soft touch LCD control panel will make this your favorite kitchen electric appliance. This unit includes an electronic timer, temperature display, ice cream scoop, and recipes.

This product comes with a one-year limited warranty.

Pros

  • Self-contained frozen dessert maker that does not require pre-freezing
  • Removable bowl and churn blade for easy storage and effortless cleaning
  • Reliable built in audible timer
  • Newly designed motor drive that shuts off to prevent damage if the mixture freezes solid

Cons

  • Customer service problems with the company
  • When overfilled, ice cream does not come out correctly
  • Canister is difficult to clean

[amazon link=”B003KYSLMW” title=”Cuisinart ICE-21″ /]

[amazon box=”B003KYSLMW”]

Price

Features

Warranty

This product can be found on Amazon for around $50.

Now you can make your favorite frozen yogurt at home in just 20 minutes or fewer! This fully automatic Cuisinart Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream & Sorbet Maker lets you turn ingredients into a delicious and healthy frozen treat with no fuss and no mess. Add your ingredients to the bowl, press ON, and the machine does the rest.

This product comes with a 3-year limited warranty.

Pros

  • New mixing paddle makes frozen desserts in 20 minutes
  • Large capacity makes up to 1-1/2 quarts
  • Double insulated freezer bowl eliminates the need for ice
  • Easy-lock transparent lid with a large spout makes adding ingredients mess-free

Cons

  • Poor customer service
  • Must let canister freeze first before adding ingredients
  • Ice cream takes longer to make than advertised

[amazon link=”B0009A0N4E” title=”Hamilton Beach 68330N” /]

[amazon box=”B0009A0N4E”]

Price

Features

Warranty

This product can be found on Amazon for around $35.

Makes up to four quarts of ice cream, frozen yogurt, custard, sherbet or gelato in under an hour. It is fully automatic, and over 20 recipes are included. There is an easy-lock lid feature.

This product comes with a one-year limited warranty.

Pros

  • Produces up to 4 quarts in 20 to 40 minutes
  • Fully automatic operation
  • Makes homemade ice cream, frozen yogurt, custard, sherbet, and gelato
  • Easy-lock lid
  • User manual with 20 recipes included

Cons

  • Requires 10 pounds of ice
  • Bolts become loose after several uses
  • Very short electrical cord

[amazon link=”B015XOPJR6″ title=”Chef’n Sweet Spot” /]

[amazon box=”B015XOPJR6″]

Price

Features

Warranty

This product can be found on Amazon for around $45.

This manual ice cream maker is easy and quick to use. After using included recipes to assemble an ice cream mixture, pour it onto the frozen Sweet Spot surface. The mixture will begin to freeze instantly. Scoop and turn with the included scoop and spade tools until ice cream forms. This homemade ice cream maker is fun to use and the results are delicious! The kids will love helping you in the kitchen when using the Sweet Spot.

This product comes with a one-year limited warranty.

Pros

  • Homemade ice cream in minutes
  •  Fast-freeze surface
  • Also makes frozen yogurt, sorbets, gelato and more
  • A scoop, spade, and recipe book are included
  • Hand washable

Cons

  • Ice cream does not get very hard
  • Must put the entire surface area in the freezer which is large
  • Only makes a small amount of ice cream at a time

[amazon link=”B005083ECS” title=”Yonanas Frozen Dessert Maker” /]

[amazon box=”B005083ECS”]

Price

Features

Warranty

This product can be found on Amazon for around $40.

This Yonanas Frozen Dessert Maker turns frozen fruit and other flavorings into delicious, healthy soft-serve. The unit combines frozen bananas and any additional fruit or chocolate and instantly churns the ingredients to produce a treat with the texture of frozen yogurt or soft-serve ice cream, but without the additional fat, sugar, or preservatives. The chute easily accepts berries, sliced mango, or cantaloupe along with frozen banana, and the integrated spinning blade mashes and incorporates the fruit into a silky-smooth confection with the texture of soft-serve ice cream or yogurt.

This product comes with a one-year limited warranty.

Pros
  • Uses frozen bananas to make the base of frozen dessert
  • Can add any fruit you desire to make a healthy treat
  • Hand washable
Cons
  • Does not make hard ice cream
  • Fruit is still chunky in the dessert
  • Only makes one bowl at a time

[amazon link=”B0002IES80″ title=”KitchenAid 2 Quart Ice Cream Maker Stand Mixer Attachment” /]

[amazon box=”B0002IES80″]

Price

Features

Warranty

This product can be found on Amazon for around $80.

Create your favorite frozen treats in no time. Create two quarts of soft-serve ice cream, sorbet, or gelato in 20-30 minutes. Allow the bowl to freeze at least 24 hours before use.

This product comes with a one-year limited warranty.

Pros
  • Makes up to two quarts of ice cream, gelato or sorbet in 20-30 minutes
  • Dasher rotates inside the bowl to spread, scrape and mix thoroughly
  • Easy to clean with warm, soapy water.
  • Some tilt-head models will require an adapter ring to fit properly
  • For use with KitchenAid stand mixers
  • Powered by stand mixer
Cons
  • Ice cream does not come out very hard
  • Paddle freezes in place
  • Not powerful enough
  • Must freeze bowl first

[amazon link=”B009OZ62IG” title=”Breville Smart Scoop” /]

[amazon box=”B009OZ62IG”]

Price

Features

Warranty

This product can be found on Amazon for around $400.

The BCI600XL Smart Scoop is Breville's easy-to-use ice cream maker with automatic hardness settings. It's the first ice cream maker that automatically senses the hardness of the mixture based on your selection and keeps it ready until it's time to serve. The Smart Scoop is made of BPA-free materials, features a child lock, and when your dessert is ready will sound an alert beep or one of three musical tunes.

This product comes with a one-year limited warranty.

Pros
  • 12 ice cream hardness settings plus sorbet, frozen yogurt, gelato
  • Self-refrigerating compressor
  • Fully automatic or manual functionality
  • Pre-cool setting for optimal operating temperature
Cons
  • Breaks easily
  • Very expensive
  • Does not freeze well

[amazon link=”B00CFIKO3S” title=”Donvier 837450″ /]

[amazon box=”B00CFIKO3S”]

Price

Features

Warranty

This product can be found on Amazon for around $70.

No salt or ice is needed to create one quart of ice cream, frozen yogurt, sorbet, or frozen drinks at home with this ice cream maker. Just turning the crank occasionally for 15 or 20 minutes is all it takes. The unit's freezer bowl goes into your freezer for about seven hours to freeze the liquid between its walls. Then the bowl then goes into the machine's outer case, the paddle goes into the bowl, ingredients are added, the transparent top locked in place, and the crank turned. In minutes, a wonderful frozen dessert is ready. The aluminum bowl cleans easily, the outer case and top are plastic so they wipe clean.

This product comes with a one-year limited warranty.

Pros
  • Makes one quart of ice cream, sorbet, frozen yogurt, or frozen drink
  • No salt or ice needed
  • Aluminum freezer bowl cleans easily
  • 9-1/2" high, 8" diameter
  • Recipes included
Cons
  • Crank handle is flimsy
  • Only makes one quart at a time
  • Must freeze ahead of time

[amazon link=”B00004RDF0″ title=”Lello 4080 Musso Lussino” /]

[amazon box=”B00004RDF0″]

Price

Features

Warranty

This product can be found on Amazon for around $730.

Fully automatic and precisely controlled by a timer, this machine takes the trouble and guesswork out of making ice cream, sorbet, frozen yogurt, gelato, and frozen drinks at home. Ingredients go into the bowl, the timer is set, two buttons are pressed and about 30 minutes later 1-1/2 quarts of a frozen confection are ready for consumption. Because the machine doesn't require its bowl to be frozen for hours in a freezer (like less expensive machines that only churn do), it can immediately begin making another batch.

This product comes with a one-year limited warranty.

Pros
  • 1-1/2-quart bowl capacity
  • Fully automatic
  • Timer controls operation
  • Housing, bowl, paddle made of stainless steel
  • 12" wide, 11" high, 18" deep
Cons
  • Machine vibrates while in use
  • Bowl is not removable
  • Very expensive

The Verdict

bowl ice cream

Image Source: Pixabay

While the familiar adage you get what you pay for is usually true, in this case we find that just because a machine is very expensive does not mean it is the best machine. After reviewing the best ice cream makers, we found that the simpler models seemed to do just as good a job as the more expensive models with built-in compressors. Yes, the less expensive models require ice or for you to freeze the bowl, but we could not fathom paying hundreds of dollars for an ice cream maker when we could get almost the same results with a less expensive model.

When following the recipes, every model produced amazing ice cream. In making your purchase choice you must consider how often you will make ice cream and how much you will make on a weekly or monthly basis. For those with a really sweet tooth or a large family, fully automatic machines make great sense. Our favorites from this best ice cream makers list were the KitchenAid mixer attachment as it was simple to use and easy to clean afterward. Equally good is the automatic Cuisinart ICE-21 Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream & Sorbet Maker. 

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Reply:

shares