Best Counter & Portable Ice Maker Reviews: A Comprehensive Guide for Buyers

Portable Ice Maker AB-ICE26S, Color Silver, By Avalon Bay

Portable Ice Maker AB-ICE26S, Color Silver, By Avalon Bay

Sometimes, we need more ice than our standard freezer can produce. How many times have you had to go to the nearest gas station just to buy several pounds of ice? If you purchase a great quality portable ice maker, you will no longer have to make such hasty trips and you'll save money in the long term because your ice maker will pay for itself.

Here are some uses and situations where it might be handy to have an ice maker:

  • camping
  • indoor/outdoor bars
  • enjoy cold pool side beverages
  • at work or in your home office
  • family reunions
  • cafes without soda/ice dispensers
  • if you own a restaurant or commercial kitchen
  • college dorm room
  • you need to replace your broken ice maker on refrigerator/freezer

But you can use your ice maker for whatever you desire, just remember that ice makers can not be used as a freezer would be. These type of ice makers stand alone and can only be used for one thing: making ice. 

In this article, you will be provided with all the details and information that you need in order to choose the best portable ice maker for your situation. We will review and compare four different portable ice makers so that you can be schooled in the best selection that’s out there.

It’s always wise to know about the product before you buy it. Well, here’s the information, details and everything that you need to know.

Let’s take a look at these four portable ice makers from Amazon.com

1. Igloo CounterTop Ice Machine Model ICE103 in Stainless Steel

The Igloo Ice Maker is made of beautiful stainless steel with a pristine design. With a high rating on Amazon.com, it currently has the lowest price of the ice makers we review on this page.

It can produce up to 26 lbs. of ice in a day and can hold up to 2  pounds and 3 oz. of ice. As for ice producing speed and frequency, from the time you pour in the water, you will have ice in 6 minutes! It's the fastest machine out of the four. 

Do you have a need or preference for ice cube size and shape? The Igloo Ice Maker allows you to choose between 3 different sizes and shapes of ice cubes.

2. NewAir AI-100R 28-Pound Portable Icemaker, Red

The NewAir Icemaker comes in a charming, deep red color. It's very easy to move and carry and is perfectly compact. Due to its lightweight and compact design, it would be excellent for any boat, camper or kitchen setting.

On Amazon.com, it's currently the most expensive of the three portable ice makers and has a great star rating. But goodness, this ice maker is a beast!

It can make 28 pounds of ice per day! That's two pounds more than the Igloo. It also gives you the choice of 3 different ice cube sizes and shapes. Unfortunately, the creation of ice from water is only 15 minutes. In comparison to the Igloo Ice Maker, that's nearly a 10 minute difference.

The NewAir Icemaker has an automatic overflow protection. This ideal for moments when you may fill the bowl too high with water.

3. Portable Ice Maker AB-ICE26S, Color Silver

The Avalon Bay Portable Ice Maker can produces the least amount of ice in a day. It can make up to 26 lbs. each day. It has a sleek stainless steel design that looks great with other stainless steel appliances. 

This ice maker produces ice in an impressive 6 minutes. However, unlike the Igloo and NewAir portable ice machines, the Avalon Bay only allows you to choose between 2 ice cube sizes and shapes.

It has the convenient automatic overflow protection and lighted reminder indicators that come in handy when you need to add water or empty the ice bucket.

4. Avanti Portable Countertop Ice Maker Model IM12CIS Color: Stainless Steel 

The Avanti Countertop Portable Ice Maker can produce up to 25 pounds of ice per day. It's design is a sleek stainless steel that looks great with other stainless appliances. 

This machine produces a fun shaped ice cube that looks like a bullet and has a cylindar style hole in the middle. These ice cube styles are great for those who like to suck on and chew ice.

This machine produces a fun shaped ice cube that looks like a bullet and has a cylindar style hole in the middle. These ice cube styles are great for those who like to suck on and chew ice.

The Avanti ice maker also comes with a tray and scoop so it makes it an awesome option. Also if the ice cubes in the maker go without being using the machine recycles the ice cubes by melting the ones its storing and uses the water to make new ones. 

So, which portable icemaker produces the most ice?

Although it doesn't produce ice in a 6 minute time frame like the Igloo Ice Maker, the NewAir wins this aspect. It produces 28 pounds of ice per day whereas the others only produce only 26 or 25 pounds per day.

Effortless Mobility

Depending on your exact needs and specific situation, generally, you don't want an ice maker that is a pain to tote around. After all, when you see the word, "portable", you are searching for something that isn't going to break your back or be a pain to move from place to place if it comes down to it.

Product Image

Effortless Mobility

Portable Ice Maker AB-ICE26S, Color Silver, By Avalon Bay

Without a doubt, the Avalon Bay Portable Ice Maker is one of the lightest machines in this group, tying with the Avanti machine. It weighs about 21 pounds and looks great on any kitchen counter, camper counter, back patio, and more.

avanti countertop portable ice maker stainless steel

The Avanti Countertop Portable Ice Maker is the same weight as the Avalon Bay ice machine. It weighs 21 lbs. making it easy to transport and great to take along on your next camping trip!

NewAir AI-100R 28-Pound Portable Icemaker, Red

The NewAir ice machine boasts on being the most lightweight; however, it is only the second lightest in the group. It weighs in at 24 pounds, only 3 pounds behind the Avalon Bay model.

Igloo ICE103 Counter Top Ice Maker with Over-Sized Ice Bucket, Stainless Steel

The Igloo Ice Maker weighs in at 25 pounds making it the heaviest option. 

If you need a portable ice machine that will be moved around a lot, the Avalon Bay or the Avanti machines win with the easiest mobility mechanism and lightweight feature, but the other machines get good reviews and our excellent machines as well. So, overall it comes down to function, mobility, and color.

Are there any easy to use controls or mechanisms?

Yes! The NewAir is the most advanced with the technological controls and mechanisms. New Air is known for using the most advanced technological advances with their products and appliances. You should expect the best in terms of tech savvy controls and aspects with their products.

It comes with a LED screen and display that allows for easy control and operation. The easy push buttons are electronic thus making it easy for anyone to figure out and operate.

Ice size selection is super easy. On the LED screen, simply select the size (all ice cubes are formed in a bullet shape) and you're good to go!

The Igloo Ice Maker also has a LED screen that closely competes with the NewAir.

The Avanti Ice Maker has user friendly buttons and controls and it's easy to figure out how to use without the user manual. It includes displays that tell you when the water needs filled or replaced and easily displays the size of the ice cubes you select. 

However, if we were to have a preference, we would say that the Avalon Bay's screen display looks the easiest to operate. Although all four portable ice makers have the simple push button screens, sometimes the design layout determines what is easiest to understand.

How much can it handle?

Probably one of the most important questions that you want to ask when shopping for a portable ice maker is "How much can it handle?". The answer to this question will help you in purchasing the best portable ice maker.

Product Image

How much can it handle?

Igloo ICE103 Counter Top Ice Maker with Over-Sized Ice Bucket, Stainless Steel

The Igloo wins this one hands down. It produces about 8 ice cubes every 6 minutes. After an hour, that's a lot of ice! It holds 2.2 pounds of ice cubes before it stops making them. With a daily production of 26 pounds of ice a day, this little machine can handle a lot.

NewAir AI-100R 28-Pound Portable Icemaker, Red

As our second place winner in the "how much it can handle" aspect is the NewAir Ice Maker. This high tech appliance produces 9 ice cubes in under 15 minutes. That seems slow for second place, so why is it the second choice in what it can handle? Because it produce 28 pounds of ice in a day! That's 2 more pounds of ice than the Igloo and Avalon Bay portable ice makers. However, according to some of the NewAir portable ice maker reviews, it can only hold about a half a pound of ice. Compare that to the Igloo's 2.2 pound limit and decide which you think is best for your needs.

Portable Ice Maker AB-ICE26S, Color Silver, By Avalon Bay
avanti countertop portable ice maker stainless steel

The Avalon Bay can produce 9 ice cubes every 6 to 13 minutes. It's capable of making 26 pounds of ice per day. However, it's unclear as to how much ice it can hold. Let's also remember that the Avalon Bay ice maker only has the option to make 2 different ice cube sizes. The Igloo and NewAir allows you to choose from 3 different ice cube sizes.

This Avanti ice maker can produce 10 cubes in ten minutes, which is around the same frequency as the NewAir and Avalon Bay makers. 

Which would be best for your specific situation?

This is another question to consider when shopping for the best portable ice maker. You want to choose the best machine for your specific situation.

Are you needing a portable ice machine for that big family reunion this summer? Are you expecting at least 50 family members? Is the family reunion going to be at the park? Well, since most family reunions involve a barbecue of some sort, they will definitely be hot and thirsty. You will want to choose the ice machine that will produce the most ice cubes in the least amount of time.

The Igloo ice maker would likely work the best in this situation. It holds up to 2.2 pounds of ice and produces 8 ice cubes per 6 minutes. Let's face it: Igloo has been long known for producing great appliances and products that are designed to keep things cold and cool. There's no doubt that it could handle the hot outdoors for a family reunion barbecue.

The next best choice for this type of scenario would be the NewAir ice maker. Like the Igloo model, it gives you the option to choose between 3 different ice cube sizes. However, as mentioned above, it produces 9 ice cubes per 15 minutes or less. What makes the NewAir stand out from the other 2 ice makers is the fact that it can produce a whopping 28 pounds of ice in a single day. That would easily serve a large family reunion get-together.

If you love to go camping with your family and friends in the summer camper, then you will enjoy the tiny, portable Avalon Bay ice maker. It's very lightweight and easy to use. This works great since most campers have very small counter space. As far as ice cube production, it matches closely to that of the Igloo ice maker. The main difference is that it only allows you to choose between 2 ice cube sizes of small and large. However, it would supply the need for ice on any hot summer day in the camper.

Finally, you need to consider the price and your budget.

If you know what you need, then it's best to have an idea of how much you're willing to spend and what you're not willing to spend.

If these options are too expensive for you, you can try to purchase refurbished ice makers from Walmart, Target or Amazon but they may not have these machines cheaper so you may have to go with a different brand like Emerson, Hamilton Beach, or Della. 

Product Image

Finally, you need to consider the price and your budget

Igloo ICE103 Counter Top Ice Maker with Over-Sized Ice Bucket, Stainless Steel

Although prices are always changing, the Igloo ice maker is currently the most inexpensive on Amazon.com. It also has the highest star rating. Knowing what you do about the Igloo ice maker, this may be a great interest to you.

Check it out on Amazon.com now for pricing

Portable Ice Maker AB-ICE26S, Color Silver, By Avalon Bay

The next ice maker that's low in price is the Avalon Bay. Although it's currently a few dollars higher than the Igloo, it's still priced at a bargain. It has a good star rating on Amazon.

Check out the price of the Avalon Bay Portable Ice Maker on Amazon.com

NewAir AI-100R 28-Pound Portable Icemaker, Red
avanti countertop portable ice maker stainless steel

Finally, the NewAir ice maker has the highest price on Amazon.com but not by far. If anything, with this machine you are paying for the extra technological advances, the lovely red color and the 28 pounds of daily ice cube production capabilities. It has a great star rating on Amazon as well.

Finally, the NewAir ice maker has the highest price on Amazon.com but not by far. If anything, with this machine you are paying for the extra technological advances, the lovely red color and the 28 pounds of daily ice cube production capabilities. It has a great star rating on Amazon as well.

See the price of the Avanti ice maker on Amazon.com

Which ice maker has the best customer reviews?

Generally, when you are shopping for something online, it's great to check out the customer reviews and see what people are saying about the product they bought. If they had great experiences with it then that means that you are likely to have great experiences with it as well. in other words, you want to buy something that is reliable, dependable and worth every hard earned penny.

The Igloo was, by far, the most popular ice maker according to the customer reviews. Don't mistake us: it's a very close call since they're all great ice makers. However, for the money and performance, the Igloo ice maker is a bargain.

The only complaint that could be found about the Igloo ice maker was where one customer stated that it was simply too big for her counter. However, everyone else seemed very pleased with its small and convenient size.

The biggest compliment to the NewAir portable ice maker reviews was its longevity. One customer proudly boasted that her NewAir portable ice maker was STILL a 5 star machine after 3 and a half years of continuous use!

Keep in mind that there is always a bad seed in a batch of good seeds. One customer left a 1 star review because he stated that his NewAir ice maker completely quit working after producing it's third round of ice.

Finally, the Avalon Bay portable ice maker has great customer reviews as well. The biggest compliment to this ice making machine is how quickly it produces the ice. Not to mention, the lightweight and small design has made customers happy with using in their motor homes and campers.

Unfortunately, there is always a bad customer review in there somewhere. For the Avalon Bay ice maker, one customer was enjoying the speedy production of the ice until it completely shut down after 10 months of continuous use. It went kaput and never operated again. Feeling distraught, the customer changed his high star rating to a disappointing 2 star rating on Amazon.com.

Overall, we hope that this article has helped you in your shopping quest for the best ice maker on Amazon.com. Happy shopping!